Modem prices range from $30 to $200, depending on the type and speed it supports
A basic modem that works with most internet plans costs between $30 and $60. Mid-range modems that handle faster speeds run $60 to $120. High-end modems designed for the fastest available plans can cost $150 to $200 or more. The price you actually pay depends on what your internet service provider (ISP) requires, how fast your plan is, and whether you buy new or refurbished.
Many people rent a modem from their ISP instead of buying one. Rental fees typically run $10 to $15 per month. Over two years, that adds up to $240 to $360 — more than the cost of buying outright. If you stay with the same ISP for three or four years, buying almost always saves money.
Key Takeaways
- Entry-level modems cost $30 to $60 and work fine for standard internet speeds up to 100 Mbps.
- Your ISP may require a specific modem model or may only rent modems to you, which limits your buying options.
- Renting a modem from your ISP costs $10 to $15 monthly and exceeds the purchase price within two to three years.
- Refurbished modems cost 20 to 40 percent less than new ones and carry the same warranty in most cases.
- A modem you own works with a new ISP if you switch providers, but some newer modems only work with specific companies.
What your internet speed determines about modem cost
Modems that support slower speeds — up to 100 Mbps — are the cheapest category. These work with basic cable internet plans and cost $30 to $50 new. If your plan maxes out at 100 Mbps, you do not need to pay more.
Modems rated for 300 to 600 Mbps cost $60 to $100. These handle mid-tier plans from most major ISPs. Modems built for gigabit speeds (1000 Mbps and above) start at $120 and can exceed $200. If your plan does not offer speeds above 300 Mbps, a gigabit modem is overkill and wastes money.
Check your internet plan paperwork or your ISP's website to find the maximum speed you pay for. Buy a modem rated for at least that speed, but you do not need to exceed it by much.
Renting versus buying: the math over time
When you rent a modem from your ISP, the monthly fee appears on your bill. Most providers charge between $10 and $15 per month, though some charge as little as $8 or as much as $20. Ask your ISP for the exact fee before you decide.
A $12 monthly rental costs $144 per year and $432 over three years. A $60 modem bought outright pays for itself in five months. After that, you own it and pay nothing more. If you switch ISPs, you can take your modem with you — as long as the new provider supports it.
Renting makes sense only if you move frequently, change ISPs often, or do not want to handle a hardware failure yourself. For most people staying with one provider for two years or longer, buying saves money.
Where ISP requirements limit your choices
Some internet providers maintain a list of modems they officially support. Before you buy, check your ISP's website for their approved modem list. If a modem is not on the list, the ISP may refuse to set up it or may not may provide it will work properly.
A few ISPs — particularly some regional cable companies — only rent modems and do not allow customers to use their own equipment. Call your provider or check their website to find out whether you have the option to buy. If you do not, you are locked into renting unless you switch providers.
Newer fiber-optic internet services sometimes require a modem that only works with that specific provider. In those cases, buying your own modem is not an option. Ask your ISP whether their modem is proprietary before you sign up for service.
New versus refurbished: when the discount makes sense
Refurbished modems cost 20 to 40 percent less than new ones. A modem that sells new for $80 might cost $50 to $60 refurbished. Refurbished units have been returned, tested, cleaned, and repackaged. Most carry the same one-year or two-year warranty as new equipment.
The risk with refurbished gear is small but real: the device failed once before, so it may fail again sooner than a new unit would. If you buy refurbished, choose a seller with a clear return policy so you can send it back if it stops working within the first month.
Buying refurbished makes sense if you are on a tight budget or if you want to test whether owning a modem saves you money before committing to a full-price purchase. For most people, the $20 to $30 savings is worth the small extra risk.
What happens when your modem fails
If you rent a modem from your ISP and it stops working, call the provider and they will send a replacement at no charge. The whole process usually takes a few days. You do not pay for the repair or the replacement unit.
If you own a modem and it fails, you pay to replace it. Most modems carry a one-year or two-year manufacturer's warranty that covers defects. If your modem fails within the warranty period, contact the manufacturer for a replacement. After the warranty expires, you buy a new modem yourself.
This is one reason some people prefer renting: they do not have to worry about replacement costs. However, modems are generally reliable and often last five to seven years. The odds of needing a replacement during ownership are low enough that buying still comes out ahead financially for most people.
Bundled modems and combo units
Some modems include a built-in router, which combines two devices into one unit. These combo units cost more than a modem alone — typically $80 to $150 — but less than buying a modem and router separately. If you need both devices, a combo unit can save money.
However, combo units have a drawback: if the router fails, you lose internet entirely because you cannot separate the two. With separate devices, you can replace just the failed piece. For most households, separate modem and router are more reliable and easier to troubleshoot.
Check whether your ISP supports combo units before you buy. Some providers do not set up them, or they set up only the modem portion and disable the router.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use any modem with any internet provider?
No. Cable internet modems do not work with fiber or DSL service. Even within cable internet, some newer modems only work with specific providers. Check your ISP's approved modem list before you buy, or ask their customer service whether a specific model will work with your account.
Is it worth buying a modem rated for faster speeds than my current plan?
Only if you plan to upgrade your internet speed within the next year or two. Otherwise, you are paying extra for capability you will not use. Buy a modem rated for your current plan speed, and upgrade the modem when you upgrade your internet plan.
What should I do with my old modem if I buy a new one?
If it still works, you can sell it online or donate it. If it is broken, check whether the manufacturer has a recycling program — many do. Do not throw working electronics in the trash if you can avoid it.
Do I need to return a modem I own if I switch ISPs?
No. You own it, so it is yours to keep. However, it may not work with your new ISP, so you might need to buy a different modem for the new service. Ask the new provider whether they support your current modem before you switch.
How often do modems need to be replaced?
Most modems last five to seven years before they fail. You may want to replace one sooner if your internet plan speed increases significantly and your modem cannot support the higher speed. Otherwise, keep using it until it stops working.