When and how to swap out your Comcast modem

You can replace your Comcast modem yourself if you own it, or you can request a replacement from Comcast if they own it. The process depends on who paid for the device. If Comcast rents the modem to you (the most common setup), you call them, they mail you a new one, and you swap the cables. If you own the modem, you buy a compatible replacement, connect it the same way, and return the old one to Comcast if you want to stop paying the rental fee.

The physical swap takes about ten minutes. The hardest part is usually figuring out whether Comcast owns your modem or you do — check your bill or call 1-800-934-6489 to confirm. Once you know, the rest is straightforward.

Key Takeaways

  • Comcast modems are rented to most customers for a monthly fee; you can see this charge on your bill as "modem rental" or "equipment fee."
  • If Comcast owns the modem, call 1-800-934-6489 to request a replacement, and they will mail it to you at no charge.
  • If you own the modem, you must buy a replacement that Comcast lists as compatible on their website before you install it.
  • The physical replacement involves unplugging the old modem, connecting the new one to the same cables, and waiting two to five minutes for it to boot up.
  • After you swap modems, you may need to restart your router and reconnect wireless devices, but you do not need to call Comcast unless the new modem does not get a signal.

Check your bill to find out who owns the modem

Open your most recent Comcast bill online or in the mail. Look for a line item that says "modem rental," "equipment fee," "gateway rental," or "internet equipment." If that line exists and shows a monthly charge, Comcast owns the modem and you are paying to use it. The fee is usually between $10 and $14 per month.

If you do not see a rental charge, you own the modem outright. You bought it yourself at some point, and Comcast is not charging you a monthly fee for it. You can still call Comcast at 1-800-934-6489 to confirm, but the bill is the fastest way to know.

Request a replacement modem from Comcast

If Comcast owns the modem, call 1-800-934-6489 and tell the representative you want to replace your modem. Have your account number ready — it is on your bill. Comcast will ask why you want a replacement (slow speeds, no signal, physical damage) and will ship a new modem to you at no charge. Shipping usually takes five to seven business days.

You can also request a replacement through the Comcast website by logging into your account, going to Services, and selecting "Equipment." Some areas allow you to schedule a technician visit instead, but mailing is the standard option and costs nothing.

When the new modem arrives, keep the old one. You will need to return it to Comcast within 30 days, or they will charge you a non-return fee of $100 to $150. Comcast includes a prepaid shipping label in the box with the new modem.

Buy a compatible modem if you own yours

If you own the modem, you must replace it with one Comcast lists as compatible. Do not buy a random modem and expect it to work. Go to the Comcast website, search for "compatible modems," and you will find a list of approved models. The list is organized by internet speed tier — XFINITY Starter, Performance, Blast, and Pro — so find your tier on your bill first.

Approved modems range from $60 to $200 depending on the model and speed tier. Older modems support lower speeds; newer ones support gigabit speeds. If you have Performance or Blast service, a $100 modem will work fine. If you have Pro service (gigabit), you need a modem rated for that speed, which costs more.

Buy from Amazon, Best Buy, Walmart, or directly from Comcast. Avoid third-party sellers on Amazon unless they are the manufacturer themselves, because used or refurbished modems may not work with Comcast's network. Check the return policy before you buy — most retailers allow 30 days.

Physically replace the modem

Unplug the power cable from the back of your old modem. Wait 30 seconds. Then unplug the coaxial cable (the thick cable that screws on) and the ethernet cable if one is connected. Set the old modem aside.

Take the new modem out of the box. Screw the coaxial cable onto the port labeled "Cable In" or "To Modem." Plug the power cable in. If you use ethernet, plug that cable into the port labeled "Ethernet" or "LAN." Do not plug anything into the port labeled "To Router" or "To Device" — that is for a separate router if you have one.

The modem will take two to five minutes to boot up. You will see lights on the front: usually a power light, an internet light, and a downstream/upstream light. When the internet light stops blinking and stays solid, the modem is ready. If the lights do not turn on at all, unplug it, wait 30 seconds, and plug it back in.

Reconnect your devices after the swap

Once the modem is running, restart your router if you have one. Unplug it, wait 30 seconds, and plug it back in. This forces the router to recognize the new modem. If you do not have a separate router — if Comcast gave you a gateway that combines modem and router — you do not need to do anything else.

Your wireless devices (phones, tablets, laptops) may disconnect during the swap. When the router restarts, they will ask for your Wi-Fi password again. Enter it and reconnect. If a device will not reconnect, forget the network in its settings and reconnect from scratch.

Run a speed test at speedtest.net to confirm the new modem is working. Your speeds should match your service tier. If they are much slower or you have no internet at all, restart the modem again. If that does not work, call Comcast at 1-800-934-6489.

Return the old modem to Comcast

If Comcast sent you a replacement, they included a prepaid shipping label. Put the old modem in a box, tape it shut, and attach the label to the outside. Drop it at any UPS location or schedule a pickup through the UPS website. Comcast must receive it within 30 days of your new modem's delivery date, or you will be charged a non-return fee.

If you bought your own replacement modem and want to stop paying Comcast's rental fee, you do not need to return anything. Just call 1-800-934-6489 and tell them you are using your own modem. They will remove the rental charge from your next bill. Keep your receipt in case they ask for proof of purchase.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to call Comcast before I replace my own modem?

No. If you own the modem, you can swap it out anytime without calling. Just make sure the new one is on Comcast's compatible list. If you rent from Comcast, you must call them to request a replacement because they own the device.

What if the new modem does not get a signal?

Restart it by unplugging the power cable for 30 seconds and plugging it back in. If the internet light still does not come on after five minutes, check that the coaxial cable is screwed in tightly at both ends. If it is and the light is still off, call Comcast at 1-800-934-6489 — there may be an outage or a problem with your line.

Can I use my old modem with a different internet provider?

Not usually. Modems are locked to the provider's network. A Comcast modem will not work with Verizon or another provider. If you switch providers, you will need a modem compatible with that provider's network.

Will I lose my internet during the swap?

Yes, briefly. From the moment you unplug the old modem until the new one finishes booting up — usually two to five minutes — you will have no internet. Plan the swap for a time when you do not need to be online.

What should I do with the old modem if I bought my own replacement?

You can keep it as a backup, sell it online, or recycle it. Do not throw it in the trash — modems contain materials that should be recycled. Check your city's e-waste program or take it to Best Buy, which recycles electronics for free.