Signs Your Modem or Router Is Failing

A bad modem or router usually shows itself through one of a few clear patterns: no internet at all, internet that cuts out and comes back on its own, speeds much slower than what you pay for, or devices that won't connect even though other devices can. The device may also feel hot to the touch, make unusual buzzing or clicking sounds, or have lights that don't match what they normally do. These signs don't always mean the device is broken—sometimes it's a loose cable or a setting that got changed—but they're the first things to check.

The tricky part is that modems and routers fail in different ways. A modem talks to your internet provider's network; a router splits that connection among your devices. When one fails, the symptoms can look similar, but the fix is different. Learning which device is the problem saves you time and money, because replacing the wrong one won't solve anything.

Key Takeaways

  • Restart both devices by unplugging them for 30 seconds, then plugging them back in—this fixes most temporary problems and should be your first step.
  • Check the lights on each device: a modem should show a steady or blinking internet light, and a router should show power and WiFi lights; missing or red lights point to the problem device.
  • Test with an ethernet cable plugged directly into the modem to see if the problem is the router or the modem itself.
  • If your modem is more than five to seven years old and failing, it may be cheaper to replace it than to repair it.
  • Contact your internet provider before buying a new modem, because they may replace it under warranty or require you to use their model.

Restart Both Devices First

Before you assume a device is broken, restart it. Unplug the modem from power, wait 30 seconds, and plug it back in. Wait two to three minutes for all the lights to stabilize. Then do the same with the router. This clears temporary glitches that cause most internet problems.

If restarting fixes the problem and it doesn't happen again for weeks or months, the device is probably fine. If the problem comes back within hours or days, move on to the next step. If restarting doesn't help at all, the device may be failing.

Read the Lights on Your Modem and Router

Each light on your modem and router tells you something. On a modem, look for a light labeled "Internet," "Online," "Link," or "WAN." This light should be solid green or blinking green when the internet is working. A red light, orange light, or no light at all means the modem isn't talking to your provider's network. A solid red light usually means the modem is powered on but not connected.

On a router, you should see a power light (usually solid green) and a WiFi light (usually solid or blinking green). If the WiFi light is off or red, the router isn't broadcasting. If the power light is off, the router isn't getting electricity. Check that the power cable is plugged in firmly at both ends—this is the most common reason a light is off.

If the modem's internet light is red or off but the router's lights look normal, the problem is the modem. If the modem's lights look normal but the router's WiFi light is off or red, the problem is the router. If both devices have lights that look wrong, restart them both again and wait a full three minutes before checking the lights.

Test With an Ethernet Cable

Plug an ethernet cable directly from the modem into a computer or laptop. Don't use WiFi—use the wired connection. If the internet works through the cable, the modem is fine and the router is the problem. If the internet doesn't work even with the cable plugged in, the modem is the problem.

This test takes two minutes and tells you exactly which device to focus on. If you don't have an ethernet cable, you can buy one for a few dollars at any store that sells electronics, or borrow one from someone nearby. The cable itself almost never fails, so you can use any ethernet cable you have.

Check for Overheating and Physical Damage

Feel the outside of the modem and router. They should be warm but not hot—you should be able to hold your hand on top without it being uncomfortable. If either device is too hot to touch, it may be overheating. Turn it off, unplug it, and let it cool for 15 minutes. Make sure the device has at least two inches of space on all sides so air can flow around it. Don't put it in a closed cabinet or under a blanket.

Look at the cables going in and out. They should be plugged in firmly and not bent sharply. A bent cable can look fine but carry a bad connection. If a cable looks damaged—cracked, pinched, or frayed—replace it. Also look for water damage, cracks in the plastic, or burn marks. These signs mean the device is failing and should be replaced.

Listen for Unusual Sounds

A working modem or router is usually silent or makes only a very quiet hum. If you hear buzzing, clicking, or a high-pitched whine, the device may be failing. These sounds usually come from a power supply that's breaking down or a fan that's struggling. Turn the device off and let it sit unplugged for 30 minutes, then plug it back in. If the sound comes back, the device should be replaced.

Don't confuse the sound of a fan running normally with a failing device. Some routers have small fans that make a gentle whirring sound when they're cooling down. This is normal. A clicking or buzzing sound is not normal.

Check How Old Your Modem Is

Modems typically last five to seven years before parts inside start to fail. If your modem is older than that and showing signs of trouble, replacement is usually the right choice. You can find the age by looking at the label on the back—it shows the manufacture date. If you bought it more than five years ago, it's probably at least that old.

Routers last a bit longer, often seven to ten years, but they also slow down as they age. If your router is more than eight years old and your internet feels slow, a new router may help. Before you buy a new modem, call your internet provider and tell them what's happening. They may replace it under warranty, or they may require you to use a modem they provide. Some providers charge a monthly fee to rent their modem, while others let you buy your own.

What to Do If You Find the Problem Device

If the modem is failing, contact your internet provider first. Many providers will replace a failing modem at no cost, especially if it's less than three years old. They may also require you to use their modem instead of your own. If you own your modem and it's out of warranty, you can buy a replacement—modems usually cost between 50 and 150 dollars depending on the speed your provider offers.

If the router is failing, you can buy a replacement from any electronics store or online retailer. Routers range from 30 dollars for basic models to 200 dollars or more for high-end ones. For most homes, a mid-range router between 60 and 100 dollars works well. If you rent your modem from your provider, make sure you buy a router that works with your modem—your provider can tell you which models are compatible.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a modem or router fail suddenly without warning?

Yes, but usually there are small signs first—a light that flickers, internet that drops for a few seconds, or speeds that are slower than normal. These signs may happen days or weeks before the device stops working completely. If you notice any of these, restart the device and check the lights. A device that fails completely without any warning is rare.

What if I restart my modem and router but the problem comes back the next day?

This usually means the device is failing but not completely broken yet. Restart it again and note how often the problem happens. If it happens every day or every few hours, the device should be replaced soon. If it happens once a week, you may have time to order a replacement without losing internet. Contact your provider if the modem is the problem—they may send a replacement faster than you can buy one.

Is it cheaper to repair a modem or buy a new one?

Buying a new one is almost always cheaper. Repair shops charge 50 to 100 dollars just to look at the device, and parts and labor can push the total to 150 dollars or more. A new modem costs less and comes with a warranty. The only exception is if your provider replaces it for free.

Can bad weather damage my modem or router?

Lightning can damage both devices if it strikes nearby, even if it doesn't hit your house directly. A power surge during a storm can burn out internal parts. If you lose internet during or right after a thunderstorm, unplug both devices and wait for the storm to pass. Plug them back in one at a time and check the lights. If they don't work, they may have been damaged by the surge. Using a surge protector power strip can help prevent this.

Do I need to replace both my modem and router at the same time?

No. Replace only the device that's failing. If the modem is bad and the router is working fine, buy a new modem. If the router is bad and the modem is working fine, buy a new router. Replacing both when only one is broken wastes money. The only reason to replace both is if they're both very old and both showing signs of failure.