A modem and a router do two completely different jobs, even though they sit next to each other
Your modem is the device that connects to your internet service provider's network and translates the signal coming through your cable, fiber, or phone line into data your devices can use. Your router takes that data from the modem and broadcasts it wirelessly (or through ethernet cables) to all your devices in your home. The modem talks to your ISP. The router talks to your devices. You need both.
Many people think of them as one unit because they sit side by side and sometimes look similar, but they perform separate functions. If your modem fails, no device in your home can reach the internet at all. If your router fails, your devices can still connect to the modem through an ethernet cable, but you lose wireless connectivity.
Key Takeaways
- A modem receives the internet signal from your ISP and converts it into usable data; a router distributes that data to your devices wirelessly and over ethernet.
- Your modem has one connection to the outside world (your ISP line); your router has one connection to the modem and multiple connections to your devices.
- If the modem fails, nothing in your home connects to the internet; if the router fails, you can still use ethernet cables to reach the internet.
- Some ISPs rent you a combined modem-router unit, but the two functions are still happening inside that single box.
- Restarting a modem and restarting a router are different troubleshooting steps that fix different problems.
What a modem actually does
A modem is short for modulator-demodulator. It takes the signal coming through your cable line, fiber optic line, or phone line—a signal your computer cannot read directly—and converts it into digital data. That conversion is the modem's only job. It has one port that connects to your ISP's network and one port that connects to your router (or directly to a device if you are not using a router).
Your ISP owns the modem or you own it, depending on your service agreement. If your ISP owns it, they may charge you a monthly rental fee. If you own it, you bought it once and it is yours. The modem sits between the outside world and your home network. It does not care how many devices you have or what you are doing with them—it just passes the data back and forth.
What a router actually does
A router takes the internet connection from the modem and shares it among all your devices. It creates a local network inside your home and decides which data goes to which device. When you connect your phone to your Wi-Fi, you are connecting to the router, not the modem. When you plug an ethernet cable into your laptop, you are plugging it into the router (or a switch connected to the router), not the modem.
The router also has a built-in firewall that protects your devices from unwanted traffic coming in from the internet. It assigns local IP addresses to each device on your network so they can talk to each other. If you have ten devices in your home, the router is the device managing all ten connections at once.
Why you cannot use one without the other
A modem alone cannot broadcast Wi-Fi or share a connection among multiple devices. It has no wireless capability and no way to manage a network. If you plugged your phone directly into a modem, it would not work—the modem has no Wi-Fi radio and only one data port anyway.
A router alone cannot connect to the internet. It has no way to reach your ISP's network. A router needs a modem to provide the internet connection it will then share. If you set up a router without a modem, the router will power on and broadcast a Wi-Fi signal, but that signal will not lead anywhere—your devices will connect to the router but have no internet access.
Combo units: modem and router in one box
Many ISPs provide a single device that contains both a modem and a router built into the same box. These are sometimes called gateways. Comcast's Xfinity service, for example, often provides an Xfinity Gateway that does both jobs. Verizon Fios provides a router that includes modem functionality. From the outside, it looks like one device, but the modem part and the router part are still doing their separate jobs inside.
If you own a combo unit, you typically cannot replace just the modem or just the router—you have to replace the whole thing. If you rent from your ISP, they may charge you a single monthly fee for the combo unit. Some people choose to buy their own separate modem and router instead of renting a combo unit from their ISP, which can save money over time.
Troubleshooting: which device is the problem
When your internet stops working, you need to know which device failed. If your modem is down, no device in your home will have internet access, even if you use an ethernet cable. If your router is down, devices connected by ethernet cable will still reach the internet, but Wi-Fi will not work.
To test this: unplug your router and plug a device directly into the modem using an ethernet cable. If that device reaches the internet, your modem is fine and your router is the problem. If it does not, your modem is the problem. When you restart a modem, unplug it for 30 seconds, then plug it back in and wait two to three minutes for it to fully boot. When you restart a router, do the same thing. Restarting both devices in order—modem first, then router—often fixes connection problems.
When to call your ISP versus when to replace your router
If your modem is failing, your ISP needs to know. If you rent the modem from them, they will replace it at no charge (though they may charge a shipping fee). If you own your modem, you will need to buy a replacement, but your ISP can help you figure out which model is compatible with your service. Modem problems are usually ISP problems.
If your router is failing, that is your responsibility. Your ISP will not help you troubleshoot a router you own, because the router is not part of their network—it is part of your home network. If you rent a combo unit from your ISP and the router part is failing, contact your ISP and they will replace the whole unit. If you own a separate router, you will need to buy a new one. A router typically lasts three to five years before performance degrades or hardware fails.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use my modem without a router?
Yes, you can plug a device directly into the modem using an ethernet cable and reach the internet. You will not have Wi-Fi and you can only connect one device at a time, but it will work. Most people use a router because they need wireless access and want to connect multiple devices.
Do I need to restart both devices when my internet goes out?
Start with the modem. Unplug it for 30 seconds, plug it back in, and wait two to three minutes. If that does not fix it, restart the router the same way. Restarting the modem first matters because the router needs the modem to be working before it can establish an internet connection.
Why does my ISP charge me a monthly fee for the modem but not the router?
If you rent a combo unit, your ISP charges one fee for both devices. If you rent only the modem, that is because the modem is part of your ISP's network infrastructure—they own it and maintain it. A router is your equipment, so you either own it or you do not. Some ISPs do charge a fee for renting a router if you choose not to buy your own.
What happens if I buy my own modem instead of renting from my ISP?
You save money over time, but you have to buy a modem that is compatible with your ISP's network. Your ISP can tell you which models work with your service. You are responsible for replacing it if it fails. You still need a router, which you can buy separately or rent from your ISP.
Can a bad router slow down my internet speed?
Yes. An older router or one placed far from your devices may not deliver the full speed your modem is receiving from your ISP. If your modem is working correctly but your devices are getting slow speeds, the router is often the problem. Moving the router to a central location or upgrading to a newer model can help.