PlayStation Plus Premium costs more than the standard tier, and whether it pays off depends almost entirely on which games you actually want to play and how much you value older PlayStation titles.
PlayStation Plus Premium runs $17.99 per month or $159.99 per year in the United States. That is roughly double the cost of PlayStation Plus Extra ($13.49 monthly or $134.99 yearly). The Premium tier adds a game catalog from PlayStation 1, 2, and PSP — roughly 400 older games — plus game trials that let you play new releases for up to two hours before deciding whether to buy.
The core question is straightforward: do you want to play those older games, and do you want to try new releases before paying full price? If the answer to both is no, Premium is not worth it. If you are chasing specific PS1 or PS2 titles that are not available anywhere else, or if you regularly buy new games at launch, the math shifts.
Key Takeaways
- PlayStation Plus Premium costs $17.99 monthly or $159.99 yearly, which is roughly double the price of the Extra tier.
- The main additions are access to roughly 400 games from PlayStation 1, 2, and PSP, plus two-hour trials of new releases.
- The older game library includes some titles you cannot buy or play anywhere else, but many are available on other platforms or through emulation.
- Game trials save money only if you regularly buy new games at launch and would otherwise buy games you end up not wanting.
- If you only play current PlayStation 5 games and have no interest in retro titles, Extra tier covers your needs at half the price.
What Games Are Actually in the Retro Library
The PlayStation Plus Premium catalog includes titles like Final Fantasy VII, Metal Gear Solid, Tekken 3, Crash Bandicoot, Spyro the Dragon, and Ape Escape. These are genuinely good games, and some are difficult to find elsewhere. However, many of the most popular PS1 and PS2 games have been re-released as standalone purchases, remakes, or remasters on modern platforms.
Final Fantasy VII is available as a standalone purchase. Metal Gear Solid exists in the Metal Gear Solid Master Collection. Crash Bandicoot and Spyro have modern remakes. The library does include games that have not been re-released — obscure titles, sports games from 20 years ago, and some Japanese imports — but you need to check whether the specific games you want are actually there before committing to the tier.
The catalog also changes. Sony removes and adds games periodically, so a title you want today might not be there in six months. This is different from owning a game outright, where it stays yours regardless of licensing shifts.
Game Trials and Whether They Save You Money
Game trials give you two hours to play new releases before you buy them. This is genuinely useful if you buy games at full price ($69.99 for PS5 titles) and sometimes regret the purchase. Two hours is enough time to know whether a game's core loop works for you, whether the controls feel right, and whether the story is pulling you in.
The math works like this: if you buy four new games per year at $69.99 each, and trials prevent you from buying even one game you would have hated, you have saved $70. Premium costs $159.99 per year, so you would need to avoid buying at least three bad games annually just to break even. For most players, that is not realistic. Most people either buy games they are confident about, or they wait for sales and reviews.
Trials are most valuable if you are the type who pre-orders games or buys at launch without waiting for reviews. If you already wait for sales, watch gameplay videos, or read reviews before buying, trials add little value.
PlayStation Plus Extra Covers Most Players' Needs
The Extra tier ($13.49 monthly) includes the entire PlayStation 5 game catalog that Sony has licensed for the service — roughly 400 current-generation games. This includes recent releases, popular franchises, and a steady stream of new additions each month. For someone who plays a variety of games and does not care about PS1 or PS2 titles, Extra is almost always the better choice.
Extra also includes PS4 games, which means you have access to thousands of titles across two generations. The library is deep enough that most players will find something to play without ever touching the retro catalog. If you are primarily interested in playing the latest PlayStation exclusives and popular third-party games, Extra delivers that at half the Premium price.
The only reason to step up to Premium from Extra is if you specifically want the older games or if you are a day-one buyer who values the trial feature.
When Premium Actually Makes Sense
Premium is worth considering if you meet one or more of these conditions: you have a specific list of PS1 or PS2 games you want to play and they are in the catalog; you regularly buy new games at launch and want to reduce the risk of bad purchases; or you are nostalgic for PlayStation's early era and want straightforward access to that library without hunting down old hardware or cartridges.
It also makes sense if you are comparing it to the cost of buying those older games separately. A used PS2 and a handful of games can easily cost $100 to $200, so if you want to revisit that era, Premium at $159.99 per year is cheaper than building a retro collection. However, that comparison only works if you actually play those games regularly — if you try them once and move on, you are paying $160 for nostalgia.
Premium does not make sense if you primarily play one or two games, if you wait for sales before buying new releases, or if you have no interest in older PlayStation titles. In those cases, Extra or even the base PlayStation Plus tier covers what you need.
How Premium Compares to Just Buying Games Outright
A PlayStation Plus Premium subscription is a rental service, not ownership. You keep access to those games only as long as you maintain the subscription. If you cancel, you lose access to the entire library — you cannot play the games you have been working through, even if you were in the middle of a story.
Buying games outright means you own them permanently. A $20 used PS5 game is yours to keep, replay, or sell. A $17.99 monthly subscription disappears the moment you stop paying. Over time, buying games on sale is often cheaper than subscribing, especially if you play the same games repeatedly or want to revisit them years later.
The subscription model works best for players who like variety and do not replay games often. If you finish a game and move on to the next one, the subscription pays for itself. If you replay games or want to own your library, buying outright is usually smarter financially.
The Real Cost Over Time
A year of PlayStation Plus Premium costs $159.99. Over three years, that is $479.97. Over five years, it is $799.95. That is enough to buy 11 to 12 games at full price, or 30 to 40 games on sale. If you are a casual player who finishes two or three games per year, you are paying roughly $53 to $80 per game through the subscription. If you are an active player who finishes 10 games per year, you are paying roughly $16 per game.
The subscription only makes financial sense if you play enough games to justify the cost. Calculate how many games you actually finished last year. If it is fewer than three, Premium is expensive. If it is more than eight, Premium might save you money compared to buying at full price.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I try a game trial and then buy the game while keeping my progress?
Yes. Your save file carries over when you purchase the full game after a trial. You do not have to start over. This is one of the few genuine advantages of the trial system — you can test a game and continue when ready if you decide to buy it.
Are the PS1 and PS2 games the original versions or remakes?
They are the original versions, emulated to run on modern hardware. They look and play the same as they did on the original consoles, including the same graphics and controls. Some games have optional enhancements like higher resolution, but the base experience is unchanged.
What happens to my game progress if I cancel my subscription?
Your save files remain on your console, but you cannot play the games themselves. If you resubscribe later, your saves are still there and you can resume. However, if you delete the games to free up space, you will need to re-read them when you resubscribe.
Does PlayStation Plus Premium include online multiplayer?
Yes. All PlayStation Plus tiers — base, Extra, and Premium — include online multiplayer access. You do not need Premium specifically for that feature. The base tier at $9.99 monthly covers multiplayer alone.
How often do new games get added to the Premium retro catalog?
Sony does not publish a regular schedule. Games are added occasionally, but the pace is slow compared to the Extra tier. If you are waiting for a specific older game to appear, it may never be added, or it might take years.