The upfront cost depends on which model you choose
PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X are priced the same at launch—both cost $499 for the standard model. However, Sony also sells a PlayStation 5 Digital Edition for $399, which has no disc drive. Microsoft offers the Xbox Series S for $299, a smaller console with less processing power than the Series X. If you want the cheapest way into either ecosystem right now, the Xbox Series S is the least expensive option.
Prices shift over time and vary by retailer, so checking current prices at major electronics stores will give you the most accurate picture. Refurbished or used models from either company cost less than new ones, though you lose any remaining manufacturer warranty.
Key Takeaways
- Xbox Series S costs $299, making it the cheapest current-generation console; PlayStation 5 Digital Edition is $399, and both standard models cost $499.
- Game Pass for Xbox costs $11.99 per month for console access or $16.99 per month for PC and cloud gaming included, while PlayStation Plus Essential is $11.99 per month.
- Exclusive games you want to play matter more than hardware cost—each console has titles the other does not have.
- Online multiplayer requires a paid subscription on both platforms, and the cost is similar between them.
- Used games and disc-based purchases on PlayStation 5 can save money over time if you buy physical copies instead of digital.
Monthly subscription costs are nearly identical
Both platforms require a paid subscription to play online multiplayer games. PlayStation Plus Essential costs $11.99 per month or $119.99 per year. Xbox Game Pass for Console also costs $11.99 per month, though Microsoft bundles it differently—Game Pass includes hundreds of games you can read and play, while PlayStation Plus Essential gives you a smaller rotating library.
If you want more games included, PlayStation offers PlayStation Plus Extra for $17.99 per month, which adds a larger catalog. Xbox's Game Pass Ultimate is $16.99 per month and includes console games, PC games, and cloud gaming. Over a year, the difference between the cheapest tiers is minimal, but Game Pass includes more games upfront, which can reduce what you spend on individual purchases.
Game prices are the same, but your buying options differ
New games cost $59.99 to $69.99 on both platforms. The real difference is how you buy them. PlayStation 5 comes in two versions: the standard model with a disc drive, and the Digital Edition without one. If you buy the Digital Edition, you can only purchase games through the PlayStation Store—you cannot buy used physical copies or borrow games from friends.
Xbox Series X and Series S are both all-digital, so you face the same limitation. However, Xbox Game Pass includes new Microsoft games on day one, which can save you money if you play titles like Starfield or Forza. PlayStation does not include new exclusive games in its subscription on release day. If you buy the PlayStation 5 with the disc drive, you can purchase used games at lower prices, which Xbox players cannot do.
Exclusive games you want determine the real cost
The console that costs less overall is the one with games you actually want to play. PlayStation exclusives include God of War, Spider-Man, Final Fantasy VII Remake, and Horizon. Xbox exclusives include Halo, Forza, Starfield, and Game Pass day-one releases. If the games you want are only on one platform, the other console's lower price does not matter.
Research which exclusive titles appeal to you before deciding. Many popular games—Call of Duty, Madden, NBA 2K, Minecraft—release on both platforms at the same price. If your friends play on one console, that often matters more than the hardware cost, since you will want to play together.
Accessories and controllers add to the total
A PlayStation 5 DualSense controller costs $74.99. An Xbox Series X controller costs $69.99. Both are expensive replacements if one breaks or wears out. Xbox controllers work on PC and older Xbox consoles, so they have more resale value. PlayStation controllers work only on PlayStation 5 and PlayStation 4.
If you want a second controller for local multiplayer, budget an extra $70 for either console. Headsets, charging docks, and storage expansion drives are sold separately and cost $30 to $200 depending on what you buy. These costs add up over time, especially if you play regularly and need replacements.
Storage expansion is cheaper on Xbox
Both consoles let you expand storage, but the cost differs. PlayStation 5 uses an M.2 SSD that you install yourself; compatible drives cost $60 to $150 for 1TB of extra space. Xbox Series X uses a proprietary Seagate Storage Expansion Card that costs $219.99 for 1TB. Xbox Series S uses the same card.
If you read many large games, you will need extra storage. PlayStation's option is cheaper and gives you more flexibility in which drive you buy. Xbox's option is more expensive but faster. The PlayStation 5 comes with 825GB of usable space; Xbox Series X comes with 802GB. Both fill up quickly if you install more than a few large games.
Backwards compatibility affects what you can play
Xbox Series X and Series S play games from older Xbox consoles—Xbox One, Xbox 360, and original Xbox titles. Some games run faster on the newer hardware. PlayStation 5 plays most PlayStation 4 games, but not PlayStation 3 or earlier. If you own a library of older games, Xbox lets you use more of them on the new console without repurchasing.
This matters if you already own games from the previous generation. If you are starting fresh, it does not affect your cost. However, if you have a collection of Xbox One games, moving to Series X or Series S means you keep playing them without buying again.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Xbox Series S powerful enough for current games?
Yes, but with trade-offs. Series S plays current games at 1440p resolution instead of 4K, and some games run at 60 frames per second instead of 120. If you have a 4K TV or care about the highest frame rates, Series X or PlayStation 5 are better choices. For a standard 1080p or 1440p monitor or TV, Series S performs well and costs $200 less.
Can I play my old PlayStation 4 games on PlayStation 5?
Most PlayStation 4 games work on PlayStation 5, though a small number do not. You need the disc version of PS5 to play physical PS4 discs; the Digital Edition cannot play any discs. Digital PS4 games you purchased transfer to PS5 automatically if you sign in with the same account.
Which subscription gives you more games for the money?
Xbox Game Pass includes more games overall and adds new Microsoft releases on day one, making it better value if you play a variety of titles. PlayStation Plus Extra has a smaller library but includes many popular third-party games. If you play only a few games repeatedly, neither subscription saves you money compared to buying games individually.
Does the PlayStation 5 Digital Edition save money long-term?
It saves $100 upfront, but you cannot buy used games or borrow physical copies from friends. If you buy games at full price digitally, you spend more over time than someone who buys used discs. The Digital Edition makes sense if you prefer digital purchases or use PlayStation Plus Extra heavily.
What happens if a controller breaks—how much does replacement cost?
PlayStation 5 DualSense controllers cost $74.99 each. Xbox controllers cost $69.99 each. Both are expensive, so budget for potential replacements if you play frequently. Xbox controllers last longer in resale value if you sell them, since they work on multiple devices.